Fretting, what is fretting? And is it occurring in your engine?
Fretting is the wearing away of metal between two machined surfaces that were designed for no movement. Several years ago we wrote about fretting between the cam gear and the camshaft. Now there is a possible problem on M-11, ISM, and N-14 electronic engines. If you’ve had a main bearing failure, this is probably the cause.
As you read this article, please do not panic. Do not pull your
oil pan and look for fretting. However, when the time comes for rebuilding or a
bearing change please pay close attention and look for the fretting.
The fretting will occur on the main bearing cap where it
seats to the engine block. This is a press or interference fit and when
the main bearing bolts are removed the main bearing cap should remain in the
block. If
there is side clearance between the main bearing cap and the engine block the
engine will have to be removed, disassembled, a new cap installed and the engine
block will have to be line bored.
On stock engines the main bearings are living as long as
the engine and in many cases this is in excess of 1,000,000 miles.
Fretting will remove enough metal between the main bearing caps and the engine block to eliminate the clearance between the crankshaft and main bearings. On N-14 engines the fretting usually occurs on number 2, 4, and 6 main bearing caps. On M11 and ISM engines the fretting usually occurs only on number 2 and 6 main bearings.
If the main bearings are showing accelerated wear
Plastigage should be used to check for bearing to crank clearance. Anyone who has
built racing engines knows what Plastigage is. For those of you who have never heard of
Plastigage, it’s a special extruded plastic thread that is used to determine the
clearance in a rod or main bearing. It’s available in various diameters. PG-1 green must be
used on the Cummins engines. It will check the clearance from .001 to .003
inches. The
minimum clearance on a Cummins crank is .002 inches.
In order to check the clearance on number 2 main bearing
you need to remove #1 and #3 caps. Remove the lower bearing half from each cap
and keep them in order. Now you need to fabricate a shim.
To fabricate the shim, take a 1.5 in. long piece of 4”
schedule 40 PVC.
That should be approximately .25 inch thick. Now, cut the circle
in half having two pieces 180 degrees in circumference. Now cut
approximately 1/8 to ¼ inch off the end of each half piece. Place one of the
plastic half pipes in number 1 and number 3 main bearing caps. Re-install the caps
into the engine and torque the main bearing bolts to only 25 ft-lbs. This shim will hold
the crankshaft up into the upper half of the main bearings.
Now remove the oil from number 2 main bearing and cap, cut
a piece of Plastigage the width of the bearing laying it across the bearing 1/4
inch off of bottom dead center. Re-install the bearing and cap then torque to
90 ft. lbs.
Then, 170 ft. lbs. and a final torque of 255 ft. lbs. This torque is for
N-14 engines built on or before November 24, 1997 and prior to engine serial
number 11871545.
Be certain to coat the capscrew with engine oil to obtain the proper
torque without having the bolt creek.
For N-14 engines built after November 24, 1997 and
beginning with serial number 11871541, up to January 5,1998 and serial number
11875596 use the following torque specs. 90 ft lbs, 170 ft lbs and 248 ft
lbs. This
series of N-14’s use a modified grade 8 bolt. The part number is 208346. This bolt has an
orange painted head.
For engines built on or after January 5, 1998 engine serial
number 11875596, you must use a 12.9 grade bolt part number 3411337. The torque specs
are as follows:
50 ft lbs, 100 ft lbs, 140 ft lbs, then turn the bolt an additional 90
degrees. This
is called the torque plus angle method.
Now remove number 2 main bearing cap, or which ever cap
your checking and measure the width of the Plastigage with the drawing on the
envelope that the Plastigage came in. If the clearance is less than .002 inches do
not run the engine.
A new main bearing cap must be installed and the block line bored. I know this must
sound extremely confusing so if you’re doing this work yourself and not familiar
with Plastigage invite a friend to your garage that builds racecar engines. He knows all about
Plastigage.
On the M-11 and ISM engines only Locktite 620 may be used
to stop minor fretting. The mating surfaces must be cleaned and
sprayed with Locktite Primer-N and allowed to dry for 5 minutes. The crank and main
bearing saddle should be masked prior to spraying the primer. A bead of Locktite
620 around the bolt hole and on the 45-degree bevel of the main bearing
cap. This cap
must be installed within 15 minutes or the Locktite will be to dry. The 620 Locktite
adds an additional 70 percent to the shear strength of the main bearing cap
joint.
Locktite and Plastigage are available at local auto parts stores. You may have to purchase the Plastigage at a speed shop.
I have more to say however I’m out of space. Don’t forget to remove the PVC spacer out of the other two main bearing caps and re-install the main bearings.
Are you ready for a three day diesel truck drag racing
event? This is
the first time an event of this magnitude will have taken place in the United
States. The
Place: Quaker
City Dragway, Salem Ohio. The date, August 9th, 10th and 11th, 2002. Bring your truck and your family and plan to
spend all three days as a guest of Dan Swindell the new owner of Quaker City
Dragway. Dan
will supply the water and electricity and you may wash your truck on his
pavement.
Friday night will be test and tune. Saturday night will
be a diesel gamblers race and Sunday will be an all diesel drags. This event is made
possible because of the help and sponsorship of Forest Lucas of Lucas Oil
Products.
Lucas Oil will be the main sponsor of the three day event. If you have never
had the opportunity to speak with Forest about lubrication you owe it to
yourself to come to this event and spend a few minutes with this man. The knowledge that
you gain will stay with you the rest of your life.
Other known sponsors will be Diesel Injection of Pittsburgh
with their new Pittsburgh Power Computers. We are looking for someone to sponsor a
Saturday afternoon BBQ. Maybe OOIDA would be interested.
We look forward to seeing you in August at
Quaker City Dragway.
For more information call Matt at 330-332-5335.
If you’re into Peterbilts you should take a look at Warren
Johnson’s new 256-page book called Peterbilt: The Evolution of Class. L.H. Bill the
founder and first president of Fageol Motors Co. laid the foundation for an
enduring company when he wrote, “We will never build to a standard lower than
the highest.
When we can buy better parts than we can make, we will buy them. When we can make
better parts than we can buy, we will make them. “ Bill established
the evolution of class when he vowed, “We will produce the best equipment or we
will produce nothing.” The company he created in 1915 became in 1939
what is now internationally known as Peterbilt Motors Company.
Theodore Alfred “Al” Peterman was a man known for his
mechanical genius.
He purchased Fageol Motors in 1939 for a total of $50,000. The first truck to
be called a Peterbilt was a chassis for Hirst Fire Truck Company. This first
completed truck was an “L” model 334 and was sold to Gannet Beckley of Stockton,
CA. The second
completed truck was an “M” model 260 and was sold to Pete Bordenave also of
Stockton. If
you love your “Pete” you’ll enjoy reading this book.
N-14 Cummins oil pan leakage.
Do you remember the old aluminum oil pans on the small cam engines that would leak engine oil due to cracks around the rear corners? Weekly we would weld and reinforce these pans to stop the oil leak. Then the stamped steel oil pan was released in 1981 and our oil leaking problems were over. So we thought. Because of the amount of engine noise emitted from the oil pan Cummins developed an insulation blanket to cover the pan. However, the insulation would retain moisture and sometimes develop rust that would eventually eat through the oil pan. A quick and inexpensive repair is to thoroughly sand or grind the rust and paint from the oil pan in a 6-inch diameter. Thoroughly clean the bare metal with brake clean or lacquer thinner to remove any dust or oil. The next step is to purchase a Swiss fiberglass repair kit from the local auto parts store. Using the angel hair matting, not the fiberglass cloth, mix the resin and hardener according to the directions on the can. You must do this in a heated garage. Fiberglass needs heat to cure. Using a flux brush apply a coating of resin to the oil pan then a piece of angel hair matting about 1” larger than the rust hole, then more resin, tapping it into the angel hair using the flux brush. Then another piece of angel hair matting 1” larger than the first piece along with more resin. Continue this process until you have applied about 5 layers of angel hair matting. Make sure there are no air pockets between the layers. Allow to harden for several hours before installing the oil pan to the engine. That is a $20.00 oil pan hole repair. If the metal is properly prepared the fiberglass patch will never come off.
The N-14 rear sump stamped steel oil pan will sometimes
crack around the rear corner bolts. To eliminate this problem Cummins
manufactures a clamping plate part number 4626248. This plate mounts
to the rear six bolts below the oil pan. This clamping plate requires four part number
4026354 and 2 part number 4026355 bolts. If your engine is equipped with the
insulation cover you need 2 of part number 4058673 bolts.
Engines produced on December 7th 1999 and later beginning with serial number 11988415 without the noise insulation cover already have this clamping plate installed. If your engine has the insulation cover and was produced on March 20th, 2000 or later and beginning with serial number 12002401, it also is equipped with the clamping plate.
This is an economic way to avoid a cracked oil pan which could become a costly repair. Do not over-tighten the oil pan bolts. The four 5/16 inch bolts located at the rear of the pan are torqued to 20 ft. lbs and the thirty two 7/16 inch bolts are torqued to 50 ft. lbs.
Not only did we leave the cat out of the bag, we now have them in our parking lot and the shop. In fact, the cats are calling on the phone in search of the Pittsburgh Power Cat Box!
Mike Robinson, the high performance Caterpiller diesel
engine technician from Washington D.C. brought a test Cat which happens to be in
a very clean 1999 Kenworth tri-axle dump owned by Kip Jones of Severn, MD. This 550-3406E Cat
has been tweaked to 621 flywheel horsepower prior to Brain Moan of Diesel
Injection of Pittsburgh installing the Pittsburgh Power Cat Box (computer). This is our first
3406E test of the new computer and what a test it was. With dual 8”
straight stacks it was rather easy to hear the 7 different power levels. After the
installation time of 3 ½ hours Kip and I headed for the hills on RT. 28 north of
Pittsburgh.
This computer has 7 different power levels, each click of the dial was
adding around 30 horsepower. We hit the first hill on level 5 and the
hammer lane was ours, 771 h.p. showing on the digital readout and 54 pounds of
turbo boost.
Kip has a switch on the instrument panel of this KW, which bypasses the
waste gate on the turbocharger, that’s why the boost was so high. We did not install
a mechanical boost gauge to verify the boost reading. The 54 pounds of
boost was showing on the digital readout on the Pittsburgh Power Box.
On the next hill I set the selector switch to
zero, which means the engine is stock, and Kip rolled his foot to the floor and
said the engine felt dead. Then we went to power level #1 and the sound
of the exhaust changed, and the truck started to accelerate. With every
additional click of the dial the exhaust was louder, the turbo began to scream
and the KW accelerated up the hill. All 7-power levels were distinguishable. On level 7 the
digital read out was 840 horsepower. Please keep in mind that this 550 Cat was
producing 621 horsepower, we added 219 horsepower with the Pittsburgh Cat
Box.
Upon returning to the shop Mike Robinson and I
both took our turn at the controls of this mountain lion, which is what is
painted on the back of the cab and the engine. We all were thrilled with the results of our
first test so Mike and Kip took two more Pittsburgh Power Cat boxes home to the
Washington D.C. area to get ready for the Alban Engines Power Day 2002 on May
the 18th. It looks to me that there will be three 3406E
Cats at the Power Day 2002 with an unfair advantage.
On Sunday, May 12, 2002 Mike Robinson
installed the second computer on another 550 3406E Caterpiller owned by Bruce
Popp of Crofton MD.
This Cat is powering a 2000 378 Peterbilt with an 18 speed transmission
with 4:11 rears.
Bruce uses this truck for lowboy hauling in the Baltimore, Washington
D.C. area. Mr.
Popp was so happy with the Cat box that he only used level 3 (90 additional
h.p.) all day Monday hauling the lowboy delivering forklifts. Bruce Popp’s other
truck is a 91 Peterbilt 379 with a 3406B Caterpiller, which produces 710 h.p. to
the ground which is 835 flywheel horsepower. As you can see, Bruce Popp is a true
connoisseur of horsepower and level 3 put a smile on his face. Bruce also owns a
high performance Dodge pickup with a “B” series Cummins engine.
The Pittsburgh Power Box also works on a C-12
Caterpiller.
Tim Soper of TWS Transportation in Indianapolis, IN. owns a fleet of 18
trucks and currently has a driver on a C-12 Cat with the Cat box set at 125
h.p.
More information on the C-12 next month and the results of Power Day 2002. Remember: Only the strong survive!